Top 10 Epic Moments in the Penguins vs Islanders NHL Rivalry
The Pittsburgh Penguins and New York Islanders have carved out one of the NHL's most compelling rivalries over decades of intense competition. From playoff heartbreak to stunning comebacks, these Metropolitan Division foes have delivered unforgettable moments that showcase the very best of professional hockey.
-
1. 1993 Patrick Division Finals: Islanders' Stunning Upset
The Islanders shocked the hockey world by defeating the heavily favored Penguins 4-3 in a thrilling seven-game series. Despite Pittsburgh featuring Mario Lemieux and Jaromir Jagr, New York's depth and goaltending carried them to one of the biggest playoff upsets in NHL history.
-
2. Mario Lemieux's Return Game vs Islanders (2000)
After a three-year retirement due to health issues, Mario Lemieux chose the Islanders as his comeback opponent on December 27, 2000. The hockey legend recorded a goal and two assists in a 5-0 Penguins victory, reminding everyone why he's considered one of the greatest players ever.
-
3. 2013 Playoff Series: Six Games of Pure Drama
The Penguins and Islanders met in the first round of the 2013 playoffs, delivering six games of back-and-forth action. Pittsburgh ultimately prevailed, but not before the Islanders pushed them to the brink with overtime thrillers and clutch performances from both sides.
-
4. Sidney Crosby vs John Tavares: Generational Talent Showdown
The battles between Sidney Crosby and John Tavares during their primes created must-see television whenever these teams met. Both players consistently elevated their games in head-to-head matchups, showcasing the skill and competitiveness that defines elite NHL talent.
-
5. Islanders' Nassau Coliseum Farewell vs Pittsburgh (2015)
In one of the final games at the historic Nassau Coliseum before the team's move to Brooklyn, the Islanders defeated the Penguins in an emotional contest. The victory helped solidify the Islanders' playoff position while giving fans a memorable send-off from their longtime home.
-
6. Evgeni Malkin's Hat Trick Heroics
Evgeni Malkin has tormented Islanders goaltending throughout his career, with multiple hat tricks against New York standing out as signature performances. His combination of size, skill, and hockey IQ has consistently created problems for Islanders defenders in crucial games.
-
7. The Matt Murray vs Thomas Greiss Goalie Duel
During the mid-2010s, goaltenders Matt Murray and Thomas Greiss engaged in several spectacular goaltending battles that decided tight games between these rivals. Their athletic saves and clutch performances often stole the spotlight from the skaters, showcasing elite netminding talent.
-
8. Brock Nelson's Overtime Winner at PPG Paints Arena
Brock Nelson has emerged as a Penguins killer in recent years, with several clutch goals against Pittsburgh including memorable overtime winners. His knack for finding the back of the net in crucial moments has made him a fan favorite and a thorn in Pittsburgh's side.
-
9. The Line Brawl at Nassau Coliseum (2011)
A heated regular season matchup in 2011 erupted into a massive line brawl that exemplified the intensity of this rivalry. Multiple players dropped the gloves simultaneously, resulting in numerous penalties and ejections while energizing both fan bases with old-school hockey passion.
-
10. Rookie Sensations Making Their Mark
Both franchises have a history of rookies making significant impacts in games against each other, from early Crosby performances to recent Islanders prospects stepping up. These debut moments often foreshadow future stars and add another layer of excitement to the ongoing rivalry.
The Penguins-Islanders rivalry continues to evolve with each passing season, fueled by divisional competition and mutual respect between two proud franchises. Whether it's playoff battles or regular season showdowns, fans can always expect intense, high-quality hockey when these Metropolitan Division rivals take the ice against each other.